Against All Odds
Alex Kershaw

Four men served in the same division, yet a record of honors can only hint at how different their wars felt. Kershaw works outward from the individual soldier.
Against All Odds. Edition cover via Penguin Random House.Alex Kershaw follows four American soldiers associated with the Third Infantry Division through a European war most readers know through a handful of famous battle names. All four received the Medal of Honor. One of them, Audie Murphy, became a celebrity, while the others are far less familiar. Giving their experiences room on the same page restores some proportion to what popular memory has preserved.
A citation necessarily draws a tight frame around an act of bravery. Kershaw can widen it to include the earlier fighting, the men involved and the enormous fatigue that an official account compresses into a few words. The book’s admiration is plain, and its selection of exceptional soldiers gives a powerful but particular view of the division. Readers who value a campaign history with recognizable people at its center will find much here. The quieter question it leaves is how differently these men might be remembered if no one had written the citations.

U.S. Army Signal Corps, SC 190308. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.
Open the full imageRead alongside
How much of a military operation can a participant actually see? Compare the reconstruction of the plan with the experience on the ground.
Black Hawk DownMark BowdenThe difficulty of explaining one day in Mogadishu lies in the fact that nobody experienced it as a single day with a single plot. A soldier in a vehicle, a crew in the air, and a Somali resident on the street each occupied a different world.
Roughneck Nine-OneFrank Antenori and Hans HalberstadtA crossroads near Debecka in northern Iraq would be an easy place to overlook on a map of the 2003 invasion. For Frank Antenori and the Special Forces soldiers and Kurdish fighters there, it was briefly the center of the war.
Reading group guide
Where does a citation for heroism leave out the work of people standing only a few yards away?
Find this book and edition
Against All Odds · Alex Kershaw · War & Military History
Cover edition ISBN 9780593183755 · Look for this edition in a library