The Lake Norman Brief · Carolina history, Lake Norman & North Carolina law · from Adkins Law, PLLCOffice 704-274-5677  ·  Text 704-231-5762

The Lake Norman Brief · from Adkins Law

History, the lake & the law.

Carolina and World War II history, Lake Norman stories, and practical North Carolina legal guidance.

Photo: Christopher Sheridan, CC BY-SA 4.0

The 47th Pursuit Squadron at Haleiwa

World War II › Special Units › Pearl Harbor

Special Units · Pearl Harbor, 1941

The 47th Pursuit Squadron

Away from Wheeler Field for gunnery practice, the squadron had armed fighters at a small north-shore strip the attackers left almost alone. Two of its lieutenants, George Welch and Kenneth Taylor, drove there under fire and took them up against the attack.

  • U.S. Army Air Forces · Hawaiian Air Force
  • Haleiwa and Wheeler Field, Oahu
  • 7 December 1941
Home fieldWheeler Field, the Hawaiian Air Force’s main fighter base, in the center of Oahu
That weekendAt the Haleiwa strip on the north shore for gunnery practice, with P-40s and P-36s
In the air2nd Lts. George S. Welch and Kenneth M. Taylor; Lts. Harry M. Brown, Robert J. Rogers, John J. Webster and John L. Dains
ClaimsWelch four, Taylor two (Craven and Cate); all Army claims that day exceed the true Japanese losses
LossesLt. Dains shot down on a later sortie, apparently by American antiaircraft fire; Taylor wounded

Fighters in rows

Wheeler Field, on the plateau in the middle of Oahu beside Schofield Barracks, was the Hawaiian Air Force’s main fighter base, and its P-40s and older P-36s were the island’s air defense. After the war warning of 27 November, Lt. Gen. Walter C. Short chose the lowest of his three alerts, the alert against sabotage. Under it, the Air Forces history explains, aircraft were grouped where they could be guarded rather than dispersed for a quick takeoff, and were on about four hours’ notice. At Wheeler the new P-40s stood in squadron lines, wingtip to wingtip, and their .50-caliber ammunition was locked away in Hangar 3 (Craven and Cate, vol. I; Arakaki and Kuborn).

Against saboteurs that made sense. Against strafing it was a disaster. Dive bombers hit Wheeler’s hangar line at about 0802 and fighters followed, raking the rows. The Army’s history records that Wheeler “lost two hangars, and more than two-thirds of its planes were destroyed or badly damaged,” and that the first attack “effectively prevented any large-scale response by Wheeler’s fighter planes.” The Army put the field’s toll at 37 enlisted men killed and 59 wounded (Chapter 5).

Two young U.S. Army Air Forces pilots, Kenneth Taylor and George Welch, standing together
2nd Lts. Kenneth M. Taylor and George S. Welch, late 1941 or early 1942. Photo: U.S. Army Air Forces photograph (public domain).

The strip on the north shore

Two pursuit squadrons were away from Wheeler that weekend for gunnery practice: the 44th at Bellows Field near Waimanalo and the 47th at Haleiwa on the north shore. Their aircraft were armed and needed only fuel and a warm-up. Because the squadrons had been dispersed for practice, not for defense, these were the fighters on Oahu with the best chance of getting into the air (Conn, Engelman and Fairchild, Guarding the United States and Its Outposts).

Haleiwa barely figures in the attack record. The Joint Congressional Committee said flatly that it “was not attacked”; the Army’s history says a single plane strafed it and did less damage than at Bellows. The Japanese apparently did not know about the small strip, or did not think it worth the trouble. That made it the one place on the island where American fighters could take off without being shot at on the runway.

Haleiwa was a short grass auxiliary strip, not a fighter base. It had other unexpected visitors that morning. Twelve B-17s of the 38th and 88th Reconnaissance Squadrons, flying in unarmed from Hamilton Field, California, after an overnight flight of about 2,400 miles, arrived over Oahu in the middle of the attack and came down wherever they could. Two of them, flown by Capt. Richard H. Carmichael and 1st Lt. Harold N. Chaffin, set down on the short strip at Haleiwa (Craven and Cate; Arakaki and Kuborn). For the rest of the morning the north-shore field held bombers that could not fight and fighters that could.

Ten miles by car

Second Lieutenants George S. Welch and Kenneth M. Taylor of the 47th were at Wheeler after a long Saturday night when the bombs began to fall. Welch telephoned Haleiwa to have two P-40s fueled and warmed up, and the two drove the roughly ten miles to the north shore by car. The Army history puts their takeoff “at or soon after 8:15 a.m.”; the Air Force history says about 0830 and notes that exact times are hard to establish (Conn, Engelman and Fairchild; Arakaki and Kuborn).

Ground control sent them toward Ewa, the Marine field west of Pearl Harbor, where they found a line of Japanese aircraft and each claimed two. Low on fuel and ammunition, they landed at Wheeler to rearm. Welch took off first. Taylor waited for what he thought was the last of the attackers to pass, was attacked just after takeoff and was wounded in the arm and leg. Welch shot down the plane on Taylor’s tail, his third claim of the day, then went back toward Ewa and claimed a fourth. The official Air Forces history credits Welch with four enemy planes (Craven and Cate, vol. I, p. 199).

They were not alone. Other 47th pilots also took off from Haleiwa: Lts. Harry M. Brown, Robert J. Rogers, John J. Webster and John L. Dains. Dains was shot down on a later sortie, apparently by American antiaircraft fire. Another P-36 from a later flight out of Haleiwa was brought down by machine-gun fire from Schofield Barracks, a measure of how quickly gunners on the ground began firing at everything overhead. None of these sorties would have happened without the squadron’s ground crews, who had the aircraft fueled, armed and running and then turned them around for the pilots who came back. Their names are not in the citations.

What the claims mean

The Air Forces history counts about 25 Army pursuit sorties between 0830 and 0930, from Haleiwa, Wheeler and Bellows. Four P-36s of the 46th Pursuit Squadron fought nine Japanese aircraft over the windward side and lost 2nd Lt. Gordon H. Sterling Jr.; 2nd Lt. Philip M. Rasmussen was credited with one. The Pacific Air Forces history totals the Army pilots’ claims at 10 destroyed, or 11 if a victory claimed by Dains before he was lost is added, against four Army fighters lost in air combat. The Army as a whole claimed 11 Japanese aircraft and the Navy 28, more than the 29 aircraft the Japanese actually lost to every cause, and some fighter claims were also claimed by gunners on the ground (Arakaki and Kuborn; Conn, Engelman and Fairchild). The claims were made in confusion, often against aircraft that others were already firing on, and could not be checked against Japanese records until after the war.

None of that diminishes what Welch and Taylor did. It places it. They were among the American pilots who fought back that morning, not the only ones, and whatever the true count, the Army’s fighters were too few and got up too late to protect anything on Oahu. Gen. Henry H. Arnold is reported to have recommended both lieutenants for the Medal of Honor. Both received the Distinguished Service Cross instead; Taylor’s was announced in War Department General Orders No. 2 of 5 January 1942.

surprised at Wheeler Field … shot down two enemy planes
Words from 2nd Lt. Kenneth M. Taylor’s Distinguished Service Cross citation, War Department General Orders No. 2, 5 January 1942, as quoted in Chapter 5. The citation records that he drove to Haleiwa and took off on his own initiative.

Afterward

Welch, born in 1918 in Wilmington, Delaware, went on to fly combat in the Pacific and is generally credited with sixteen Japanese aircraft in all. He left the service as a major in 1944 to become a test pilot for North American Aviation and was killed on 12 October 1954 when an F-100A Super Sabre broke up in a test dive near Rosamond Dry Lake, California. Taylor, born in Enid, Oklahoma, in 1919, retired from active duty as a colonel in 1967 and from the Alaska Air National Guard as a brigadier general in 1971. He was a technical adviser on the 1970 film Tora! Tora! Tora! and publicly criticized the 2001 film Pearl Harbor, which drew loosely on his story. He died in 2006.

The insignia, rendered

Shoulder-patch rendition
Roundel rendition
Pocket patch

Illustration Original insignia-style artwork made for the Lake Norman Brief. It is not the unit’s official emblem. The wings borrow the general look of Air Corps insignia of the period; the drawings are not based on the squadron’s own emblem.

Illustration A painted fuselage panel in the style of the period, made for this page. Not a reproduction of a specific aircraft.

Timeline

  1. A war warning reaches Hawaii; Short orders the alert against sabotage, and Wheeler’s fighters are lined up to be guarded.
  2. The 47th is at Haleiwa and the 44th at Bellows for gunnery practice.
  3. About 25 dive bombers hit Wheeler’s hangar line; strafers follow.
  4. Welch telephones Haleiwa to have two P-40s readied; he and Taylor drive about ten miles from Wheeler.
  5. Welch and Taylor take off from Haleiwa and are sent toward Ewa; each claims two.
  6. Rearming at Wheeler, Taylor is wounded on takeoff; Welch shoots down his attacker and claims a fourth near Ewa.
  7. Lt. John L. Dains is shot down, apparently by American antiaircraft fire.
  8. War Department General Orders No. 2 announces Taylor’s Distinguished Service Cross.
  9. Welch is killed testing an F-100A near Rosamond Dry Lake, California.

People of the unit

Read the full story

By the numbers

The 47th Pursuit Squadron by the numbers

6pilots of the 47th known to have taken off from Haleiwa: Welch, Taylor, Brown, Rogers, Webster and Dains
~10 midriven by car from Wheeler to the north-shore strip under attack
2/3+of Wheeler Field’s aircraft destroyed or badly damaged, by the Army’s history
37enlisted men killed at Wheeler, with 59 wounded, by the Army’s count
~25Army pursuit sorties flown between 0830 and 0930, from Haleiwa, Wheeler and Bellows
2Distinguished Service Crosses, to Welch and Taylor

Claims against losses, 7 December 1941

American claims of Japanese aircraft destroyed, set against what the Japanese actually lost to every cause. Many claims overlapped, and some were made by pilots and gunners for the same aircraft

Japanese aircraft actually lost, all causes
29
Claimed by the Navy
28
Claimed by the Army
11
Army fighters lost in air combat
4

Source: Leatrice R. Arakaki and John R. Kuborn, 7 December 1941: The Air Force Story; Conn, Engelman and Fairchild, Guarding the United States and Its Outposts (1964); Chapter 5

The Army fighters’ hour

Army pursuit effort over Oahu, about 0830–0930, and the 47th’s two best-known pilots. Claims as credited at the time, not checked against Japanese records

Army pursuit sorties, all fields, about
~25
Army pilots’ claims, all squadrons
10–11
Claimed by 2nd Lt. George S. Welch
4
Claimed by 2nd Lt. Kenneth M. Taylor
2

Source: W. F. Craven and J. L. Cate, The Army Air Forces in World War II, vol. I (1948), pp. 198–200; Arakaki and Kuborn; Chapter 5

In pictures

More photographs

The original hand-drawn plot sheet from the Opana radar station showing the approach of the Japanese aircraft north of Oahu
The warningThe plot from the Army’s Opana radar station at the northern tip of Oahu, 7 December 1941, tracking the incoming formation from the north. The warning did not reach the fighter squadrons in time. U.S. Army; public domain.
A Japanese Zero fighter lifts off the flight deck of the carrier Akagi as crewmen cheer
The opponentsA Zero leaves the carrier Akagi for the attack. Japanese fighters strafed Wheeler’s rows of P-40s and P-36s and met the few American fighters that got up. Japanese Navy photograph; public domain.
The burned-out fuselage of a B-17C bomber, broken in two, lies near a hangar at Hickam Field after the Japanese attack
Unarmed arrivalsB-17C 40-2074 burned out at Hickam Field. Twelve unarmed B-17s flew in from California in the middle of the attack; two of them set down on the short strip at Haleiwa beside the 47th’s fighters. U.S. Navy photograph 80-G-32915, National Archives; public domain.

In the art of World War II

Insignia, posters and art

Explore the Art of World War II →

Sources

  • Stetson Conn, Rose C. Engelman and Byron Fairchild, Guarding the United States and Its Outposts, United States Army in World War II (1964), ch. VII.
  • W. F. Craven and J. L. Cate, eds., The Army Air Forces in World War II, vol. I (1948), pp. 198–200.
  • Leatrice R. Arakaki and John R. Kuborn, 7 December 1941: The Air Force Story (Pacific Air Forces Office of History).
  • Joint Committee on the Investigation of the Pearl Harbor Attack, Report (1946).
  • Military Times Hall of Valor, Distinguished Service Cross citation for Kenneth M. Taylor; U.S. Department of Defense, “Pilots Fought Back Heroically Against Pearl Harbor Attack”; U.S. Air Force, “Historian revisits Dec. 7, 1941.”
  • U.S. Army, “70th anniversary: Wheeler attacked” (2011).